OlympIQ
NSEB topic read · 4 min

Read Comparative Excretion

A focused NSEB read for the comparative excretion pattern. Learn the linked concept, then apply it in the source questions.

NSEJS · Excretory Products and Their Elimination · 1 linked question · 100% coverage
Know this first

Comparative Excretion is the central idea in this question pattern. Identify the condition in the stem before applying the method below.

Study deeper: NCERT Science · Excretory Products and Their Elimination

Salt Glands

Fish intake relates to gland-size adaptation. The graph shows a negative relationship between percent fish in diet and relative salt-gland depression size: species eating more fish tend to have smaller salt-gland depressions, whereas those eating more marine invertebrates have larger ones. This supports B. The outlying Adelie penguin is consistent with a recent shift from a fish-rich to a krill-rich diet, so gland morphology may lag behind diet, supporting D.

Comparative Excretion

Nephridia, Malpighian tubules and related structures. Earthworms excrete through nephridia, not antennal (green) glands; those glands are characteristic of crustaceans. The other listed pairings are correct.

Comparative excretion and osmoregulation

Trace the excretory route before naming the organ: earthworm coelomic fluid enters a metanephridium through its nephrostome and exits via a nephridiopore. Aquatic vertebrates instead adjust kidney and gill transport to their salinity; seawater teleosts drink seawater and actively excrete excess salts.

Aglomerular fish in dilute water

First separate the water and ion problems. In the stated aglomerular-toadfish model, moving to much more dilute seawater requires tubular solute excretion and stronger branchial and intestinal solute uptake. Therefore choose B and D. Do not reverse the direction of water flow or predict a rise in plasma osmotic pressure.

OlympIQ exam lens

  • ✓Fish intake relates to gland-size adaptation
  • ✓Nephridia, Malpighian tubules and related structures
  • ✓Aglomerular fish: test water balance and ion balance separately.
Keep the pattern precise

Read the conditions in the stem carefully and use the stated model, labels, or assumptions before choosing an answer.

Ready to try the pattern?

100% coverage across the linked question.

Practise the linked question
Sign in to practise — your XP, streak and analysis update as you solve.